Panama, New York
Scoop the
Goodness
Handcrafted ice cream, made fresh daily with real ingredients and a whole lot of love.
Scroll
Panama, New York
Handcrafted ice cream, made fresh daily with real ingredients and a whole lot of love.
Lenny's Ice Cream Shack started as a summer dream on a quiet corner of Panama-Bear Lake Road. What began with a single freezer and a handful of recipes has grown into the neighborhood's favorite spot for cold, creamy, unforgettable treats.
We source real dairy, churn in small batches, and never cut corners. Every scoop carries the same warmth and care you'd expect from your local ice cream joint — because that's exactly what we are.
Our menu rotates with the seasons. Stop by — there's always a new favorite waiting.
Real Madagascar vanilla, slow-churned to creamy perfection.
Double cocoa, dark and velvety. For the serious chocolate lovers.
Sweet summer berries, folded into every scoop.
Cool mint, generous chocolate chunks. A timeless combo.
Dairy-free, bright, and bursting with real mango.
Vanilla base loaded with warm-baked cookie pieces.
Flavors change weekly. Ask about our rotating seasonal specials when you visit.
Every scoop is served with genuine warmth. That's the Lenny's way.
No artificial shortcuts. Just real milk, cream, fruit, and chocolate.
We churn small batches daily so you always get the freshest flavor.
A local spot for locals. Come visit us on Panama-Bear Lake Road.
We're open most days and always happy to see you. Grab a cone, grab a cup, or grab a family-sized tub to take home.
Address
861 Panama-Bear Lake Rd
Panama, NY 14767
Phone
(716) 450-2960Hours
Mon–Sat: 11 AM – 9 PM
Sunday: 12 PM – 8 PM
Ready for a Scoop?
Stop by Lenny's Ice Cream Shack today — or give us a call to place a pickup order for the whole family.
